systemd 256.1: Now slightly less likely to delete /home

Following closely after the release of version 256, version 256.1 fixes a handful of bugs. One of these is emphatically not systemd-tmpfiles recursively deleting your entire home directory. That's a feature.

The latest release of systemd, version 256.1, is out, containing some 38 minor changes and bugfixes. Among these are some changes to the help text around the systemd-tmpfiles command, which describes itself as a tool to "Create, delete, and clean up files and directories." Red Hat's RHEL documentation describes it as a tool for managing and cleaning up your temporary files.

That sounds innocuous enough, right?

It isn't, as Github user jedenastka discovered on Friday. He filed bug #33349 and the description makes for harrowing reading, not just because of the tool's entirely intended behavior, but also because of the systemd maintainers' response, which could be summarized as "you're doing it wrong".

The systemd-tmpfiles command manages files according to a specification file called tmpfiles.d, and, among many others, it has an option called --purge, which sounds quite handy according to its own manual page:

Among the issues fixed in version 256.1 are that even as long as five years ago, systemd-tmpfiles had moved on past managing only temporary files - as its name might suggest to the unwary. Now it manages all sorts of files created on the fly... such as things like users' home directories. If you invoke the systemd-tmpfiles --purge command without specifying that very important config file which tells it while files to handle, version 256 will merrily purge your entire home directory.

That fun little nugget of info broke over on Mastodon and has attracted considerable attention. Some of this has been directed at the first response to the bug report, from systemd team member Luca Boccassi:

If Boccassi's name is unfamiliar to you, he is the chap who came up with the pithy line "now with 42% less Unix philosophy" which we reported in our story on the release of systemd 256.

No, it did not originate with systemd daddy Lennart "Agent P" Poettering. We do note, however, that Boccassi is Poettering's colleague at Microsoft... And we used the line not only for its Hitchhikers Guide reference, but because it genuinely made us chuckle. In the delicate world of open source politics, though, perhaps a smidgen more diplomacy is sometimes needed.

Thus, despite an initially rather hostile response along the lines that the command was only doing what it said on the tin, always read the label, may contain nuts, etc, this command has now sprouted a few more warnings. Now, the --purge subcommand insists on a specification file, the command summary is more explicit and admonishes care, there's a warning in the man page, and the description of the systemd-tmpfiles tool no longer contains the word "temporary". It isn't much, but it's something. This is among other modest changes, of course.

It's a useful reminder to all concerned. We're all busy, and nobody has time to read the docs in full every time. Names matter, and the wider world probably won't notice when you change what a tool does if its name still refers to a now-obsolete definition.

A small joke can ricochet around the world in the time that it takes one erroneous command to wipe all your data, which - thanks to SSDs - happens more quickly than ever. These tools are written and maintained by small teams of mere humans, and humans mess up occasionally. And if your command can potentially do something really dangerous, then don't let people just run it without warning them and checking. ®

Search
About Us
Website HardCracked provides softwares, patches, cracks and keygens. If you have software or keygens to share, feel free to submit it to us here. Also you may contact us if you have software that needs to be removed from our website. Thanks for use our service!
IT News
Jul 13
Game dev accuses Intel of selling 'defective' Raptor Lake CPUs

High-end processor instability headaches, failures pushed one studio to switch to AMD

Jul 12
White House urged to double check Microsoft isn't funneling AI to China via G42 deal

Windows maker insisted everything will be locked down and secure - which given its reputation, uh-oh!

Jul 12
PowerToys bring fun tweaks to Windows 10 and 11

Friday FOSS Fest Mac migrants (if any exist) will find Powertoys Run strangely familiar

Jul 12
New Outlook set for GA despite missing some key features

Classic Outlook for Windows shuffles a little closer to the end of the road

Jul 12
Google can totally explain why Chromium browsers quietly tell only its websites about your CPU, GPU usage

OK, now tell us why this isn't an EU DMA violation - asking for a friend in Brussels

Jul 12
SAP's bid to woo open source community meets muted response

German software giant says open source is a 'catalyst for innovation' but is unlikely to release proprietary code

Jul 12
Stop installing that software - you may have just died

On Call They're called role-playing games for a reason ...