Why is Big Tech hellbent on making AI opt out?

Opinion Copilot in Microsoft 365 and Apple Intelligence on iDevices are the latest examples of the tech industry's obsession with making services opt-out rather than opt-in.

Last week, Copilot made an unsolicited appearance in Microsoft 365. This week, Apple turned on Apple Intelligence by default in its upcoming operating system releases. And it isn't easy to get through any of Google's services without stumbling over Gemini.

Regulators worldwide are keen to ensure that marketing and similar services are opt-in. When dark patterns are used to steer users in one direction or another, lawmakers pay close attention.

But, for some reason, forcing AI on customers is acceptable. Rather than asking "we're going to shovel a load of AI services into your apps that you never asked for, but our investors really need you to use, is this OK?" the assumption instead is that users will be delighted to see their formerly pristine applications cluttered with AI features.

Customers, however, seem largely dissatisfied. For every study showing how users are delighted when presented with generative AI tools, others paint a picture of users regarding the technology with suspicion and some enterprises giving the services a wide berth.

While we'd hesitate to use the word "enshittification" to describe what this relentless drive to ram AI down customers' throats is doing to formerly reliable services (take a look at the sometimes hilariously inaccurate summaries that now appear at the top of Google search results), it is clear that things are not going entirely to plan.

Customers have not asked for any of this. There has been no clamoring for search summaries, no pent-up demand for the revival of a jumped-up Clippy. There is no desire to wreak further havoc on the environment to get an almost-correct recipe for tomato soup. And yet here we are, ready or not.

This might not be what investors and shareholders want to hear, yet there needs to be a moratorium on adding AI services without first asking customers for consent. Despite promises of local processing and privacy-first technology, it is difficult to shake off the suspicion the data is being gathered for all manner of purposes. There would be (and has been - we're looking at you, Windows Recall) an outcry if spyware and keyloggers were suddenly forced on users, but generative AI assistants and summarizers appear to have got a free pass.

Microsoft has bet an awful lot on generative AI tech, and by making Copilot opt-out rather than opt-in, the company can show figures to shareholders that AI is going swimmingly and it hasn't made a terrible, terrible mistake. The same applies to Apple, Google, and many others in the tech industry.

This is not to deny the tangible benefits of AI. The technology works well as a classifier. For example, spotting potholes. As the next generation of autocomplete for coders, it can be useful. It's also handy when searching, although, let's face it, Windows Search has never been the jewel in the crown of Microsoft's flagship operating system.

Yet turning up unbidden in productivity apps smacks of a 21st-century Clippy. Particularly when a hunt is required to find the setting that switches the damn thing off.

So much money is being poured in, and the AI bubble appears close to bursting. Perhaps the pinprick of reality which arises from actually asking what customers want before giving it to them is unthinkable.

After all, the benevolence of the tech industry has always looked after customers. Nobody asked for never-ending updates, and yet here we are. Constant redesigns and refinements of user interfaces rarely hit the top ten lists of feature requests, yet customers get them anyway.

Without a choice to opt in, the beatings will continue until AI adoption improves or users find that pesky opt-out option. ®

Search
About Us
Website HardCracked provides softwares, patches, cracks and keygens. If you have software or keygens to share, feel free to submit it to us here. Also you may contact us if you have software that needs to be removed from our website. Thanks for use our service!
IT News
Feb 11
Intel loses another exec as datacenter, AI chief named Nokia CEO

Justin Hotard tapped to replace Pekka Lundmark at the Finnish telco

Feb 10
Meta's plan to erase 5% of workforce starts today

'Intense year' ahead, warned Zuck. Got to spend billions on AI and work to stay out of Trump's bad books

Feb 10
The biggest microcode attack in our history is underway

Opinion When your state machines are vulnerable, all bets are off

Feb 10
CentOS Connect conference announces return of Firefox

FOSDEM 2025 OKD project also has its own immutable CentOS image, which could be fun

Feb 10
Legacy systems running UK's collector are taxing - in more ways than one

Costs for fixing them and keeping them working up by 390%, NAO report reveals

Feb 10
Cloudflare hopes to rebuild the Web for the AI age - with itself in the middle

Also claims it's found DeepSeek-eque optimizations that reduce AI infrastructure requirements

Feb 8
'Maybe the problem is you' ... Linus Torvalds wades into Linux kernel Rust driver drama

Open source project chief hits out at 'social media brigading'